The internet’s creepiest, cookiest, and all together ookiest dream is coming true. Oscar Isaac, who you’re going to see this week in the latest Star Wars film (if you haven’t seen it 5 times already, that is), is in talks to voice Gomez Addams in the upcoming Addams Family film.

The internet has been campaigning to Isaac to step into the role of Gomez Addams for a while now. Pairing him up with an Eva Green or Ruth Negga Morticia, it’s been generally agreed that the actor is perfect for the role. Unfortunately, as we’ve previously shared, this will not be a live action film, but still, seeing this fan casting dream come to fruition in some form is pretty great.

There has been no word as to who else is being eyed for the role—or any other member of the Addams clan—but we will definitely keep you posted.