Tattoos are pretty amazing pieces of art that stay immortalized on a person’s body and sometimes tell some incredible stories. The guys of One Direction are no strangers to the needle, with three out of the members – Liam Payne, Louis Tomlinson and Harry Styles – all with their own collection of ink.

Hilariously odd games on late night talk shows are nothing new, but on the  Late Late Show with James Corden, the host came up with the brand new (slightly nerve-wracking) game of Tattoo Roulette.

The game was simple: the boys of One Direction and Corden would pick one box at random. Four boxes had the word “Safe” on the inside with the remaining box having the word “tattoo,” which would decide which person would be going under the tattoo needle live on the show. If a member of One Direction lost, “Late Late” would be tattooed somewhere. If Corden lost, he would receive “1D” tattooed somewhere on his body.

Corden and Niall Horan were nervous throughout the game since they have a combined total of ZERO tattoos. Payne, Tomlinson and Styles were all entertained by the game, prepared to add to their collection of ink.

Styles kept adding to the intensity of the game as it went along and it seemed that karma had the last laugh with Styles being the one to get the tattoo box. The newest ink was added to his collection on his left arm before the group went on to perform on the Late Late Show.